Comparison
Budgey vs Actual Budget
The open-source, local-first envelope app Reddit names as the cheaper YNAB.
Actual Budget is the YNAB-shaped app people recommend when they do not want to pay YNAB prices: envelope budgeting, cash you already have, a file you own, and an optional self-hosted server so every device stays in sync. The software is free. Multi-device sync means Docker or a host such as PikaPods (~$1–2/month). US and Canadian bank sync is SimpleFIN on top of that ($1.50/month or $15/year); EU/UK uses GoCardless.
Budgey is the hosted, paycheck-shaped version of the same job. You do not run a server. Budgets follow weekly, biweekly, or monthly pay instead of a calendar envelope month. Core includes live bank sync for 1 bank or card, with a Review Inbox so imports do not land unapproved. Plus is for 2 or more banks or budgets. Ask Budgey, or connect your own agent over MCP, if you would rather type a question than scroll a register.
Pick Actual if privacy, owning the file, and YNAB-style envelopes are the point, and you are willing to host. Pick Budgey if you want what's left of your paycheck on your phone and the web without ops. Core is $5/mo or $40/yr and does not require Docker. Periods match payday.
Budgey vs Actual Budget, feature by feature
| Feature | Actual Budget | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Core $5/mo or $40/yr. Plus $10/mo or $100/yr | Free (self-host); ~$1–2/mo hosted + SimpleFIN if you sync banks |
| Starting price | Core $5/mo or $40/yr | Yes — open source; hosting and bank sync are optional extras |
| Platforms | iOS, Android & Web | Desktop, self-hosted web, iOS & Android (mobile is secondary) |
| Bank syncNew transactions land in a Review Inbox with AI-suggested categories. You approve each one. | Core: 1 bank or card. Plus: 2 or more banks or budgets | Optional — SimpleFIN (US/Canada, paid separately) or GoCardless (EU/UK) |
| AI assistant you can chat with | Budgey — ask questions, add transactions, get insights | ✗ |
| AI receipt scanning | ✓ | ✗ |
| Pay-period budgeting (weekly / biweekly / monthly)Budget by paycheck instead of forcing calendar months. | ✓ | You budget by envelope for the month, using the cash you already have. |
| Shared budgets | Yes, on Core and Plus | Yes — anyone with access to your Actual server |
| Works with Claude, ChatGPT & other AI agents (MCP) | Yes — 70+ tools at budgeyapp.com/mcp | Local developer API; not a hosted MCP server |
| CSV / spreadsheet import | Yes. Upload a file and Budgey imports it on Core and Plus | Yes — CSV, QIF, OFX, QFX, plus YNAB importers |
Actual Budget pricing and features verified September 2026 and may have changed — check their site for current details.
Which one should you pick?
Choose Budgey if…
- ✓You want iOS, Android, and web without running Docker, PikaPods, or a home server
- ✓You get paid weekly or biweekly and want periods that match payday, not envelope months
- ✓You want Plaid bank sync with an approval inbox, not a separate SimpleFIN subscription
- ✓You want Budgey or Claude/ChatGPT on the budget, not a local-only API
Choose Actual Budget if…
- ✓You want YNAB-style envelopes and “only budget money you have” without paying YNAB
- ✓Local-first privacy and a budget file you can copy, back up, and read matter more than polish
- ✓You are comfortable self-hosting, or paying a few dollars a month for PikaPods
- ✓You want the Actual community, custom reports, and a local API for your own scripts
Budgey vs Actual Budget: your questions
Is Actual Budget or Budgey the better cheap YNAB alternative?+
Actual is the closer YNAB clone: envelopes, cash on hand, a file you own. Budgey is hosted on iOS, Android, and web, and budgets by paycheck. Core is $5/mo or $40/yr. Plus is $10/mo or $100/yr. If the method is the product, Actual (or YNAB). If what's left of your paycheck is the product, Budgey.
Is Actual Budget actually free?+
The app is free and open source. Syncing across devices means you host it (or pay a host like PikaPods, often around $1–2/month). US/Canada bank sync is SimpleFIN at $1.50/month or $15/year. Many people still spend under $40 a year all-in. Budgey Core needs no server. Live bank sync for 1 bank is on Core. Plus covers 2 or more banks.
Does Budgey work offline and keep data on my computer like Actual?+
No. Budgey is a cloud app with a phone and web client. Actual is local-first with optional end-to-end encryption. If “the file never leaves my machine” is a hard requirement, Actual is the fit.
Can I import Actual Budget data into Budgey?+
Yes. Export each account as CSV from Actual, then upload the files to Budgey. See budgeyapp.com/switch/from-actual-budget. Actual’s native budget-file backup is for Actual, not for Budgey.
See what's left of your paycheck
Auto from real money shows what's left of your paycheck, so you can sell the yes. Core is $5/mo or $40/yr. Plus is $10/mo or $100/yr.
Core $5/mo or $40/yr · Plus $10/mo or $100/yr · iOS, Android, and Web